Best Cake Eyeliner Black

Eyeliner 25 Sep 2022 10+ Comments Open



A pressed powder eyeliner duo with a bright color payoff. Two absolutely essential shades of black and brown are included. Use a brush to apply eyeliner. The brush needs to be wet to get the payoff. The item is new and unused.

Brand: Nyx Professional Makeup

👤I thought the cake eyeliner was supposed to have water added to it to make it liquid. That is my understanding of what a cake eyeliner is supposed to be. It's not worth the high cost if it's only suppose to be applied dry. I could use my own shadows to do the same thing. While working the droplets in with a liner brush, the dry powder of the cake sat atop the brush, refusing to reabsorb any moisture, because the product is so dehydrated that it does not want to absorb any water. It dropped onto everything. Face mostly. I give it a single star rating because of this.

👤It was broken within its container. The dust is pure. I had to go back and get another. I was disappointed that the replacement had no brush. I had to buy a brush kit because I didn't know the size. I tried it with several brushes. I had to remove the makeup from my eye because of the powder. I had to blow on the brush and shake it off. Didn't go as smoothly as I had hoped. Disappointed.

👤I have had this for about a month. I love using cake eyeliners. This is a mixed review. The black does not absorb liquid. I've tried water and cake eyeliner sealant, but it doesn't stick to the powder. I have to use a lot of the powder to get the liquid out of the cake, because it does absorb. The way I have used cake eyeliners in the past is the same way I use the brown cake. I am trying to make it work so it doesn't work the way it should.

👤The eyeliner is very messy and difficult to apply. The cake doesn't stick to the brush if you use a wet or dry brush. If you're not careful, it can fall out of your eye area. The powder beads up and rolls off the surrounding surfaces if you wet it. It's nearly impossible to get the water beads and powder to fit into the brush. You have a blob at the tip of the brush. If you can get any of this product onto your eye, the color intensity is inconsistent and cannot be applied very darkly. The photo of my eye was taken with the brush. It's not ideal for a winged look because it smudges out over the course of an evening. It's difficult to remove once it is smudged and faint.

👤I have been using cake eyeliner for a long time. I applied this liner to my eyes. There were black arches on my upper lids when I arrived at my friends wedding. One hour. I don't carry makeup in my purse. I only apply lipstick once I reach my destination. It isn't on my face when I leave the house. I had to remove my eye makeup at the event, and as a result only mascara was left. I didn't want to use public restroom soap, paper towel, or eye makeup on my clothes because it was annoying. There is no recommendation here.

2. Julep Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Available

Julep Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Available

Black eyeliner is best with a deep, black shade. This eyeliner pencil glides smoothly on your lashes and sets for a long- lasting finish that's been tested for 10 hours of wear. This gel eyeliner is made with a special wax blend that ensures color glides on gently without tugging or skipping. It works well for both top lashes and your inner waterline. The high- performance pigments give a bold color payoff all day long. The unique formula combines the ease of a regular eyeliner pencil with the smoothness of a gel eyeliner, so you'll get perfect, vibrant color in a single swiped. There are a variety of shades, including bold black and classic neutrals, available in both shimmer and matt finishes. There are a variety of shades, including bold black and classic neutrals, available in both shimmer and matt finishes. How to apply? It's safe for the waterline and you can glide this gel eyeliner pencil easily. Do you want a smoky finish? Smudge gently with your fingers or a brush.

Brand: Julep

👤The gel pencil stays put all day. It took me a while to figure out that you can use a pencil sharpener to sharpen this, even though you are not using wood. It does work, but you might need to clean the blades with alcohol if they get gummed up, and if you find the pencil spinning without sharpening. Try putting the pencil in the freezer for an hour.

👤The struggle is real and I have a makeup addiction. I'm an equal opportunity makeup nerd, I have everything from bargain to luxury cosmetics. I have very sensitive eyes and I need to be very careful when selecting eye products that contain glitter or shine. I gave it a try in the hopes that it would work for me. The Julep "When Pencil Met Gel" Long Lasting Gel Eyeliner is a medium sized pencil. It glides on smoothly and is easy to smudge or blend if done immediately, so it's important to smudge it upon application. I have dry eyes. I didn't have any problems with applying this. The liner was put in place all day. The shade is shimmery, not overly shiny, but it's enough to make my eyes brighter. It's very pretty and has become my go to liner for everyday wear. It's similar to the Stila 24 Hour eyeliner pencil but less expensive. This is my first Julep purchase, but it won't be my last. It's a lovely formula. I'm very impressed!

👤I have tried many waterproof eyeliner pencils over the years and this one is by far the best. The pencil does not break when it is sharpened. The infused gel allows for a smooth gliding application without tugging at delicate eye tissue. The eyeliner stays on all day. It comes in my favorite color, forest green, which makes my hazel eyes brighter. I hope that this product will be around for a long time since it is difficult to find superior makeup.

👤This eyeliner was too dark for my skin tone and age. It was easy to apply for me. I was hoping for a little more light plum, but it lasted all day and I used it lightly. It was too harsh for a lady my age. I'll either stick to the right colors or look for a lighter shade of plum. My granddaughters will be happy to use this. It will not go to waste. There is no picture submitted at this time.

👤I've been looking for makeup brands that are vegan, cruelty-free and made with clean ingredients, and that care about the environment. It seemed like it would fit my criteria after reading so many positive reviews. The eyeliner was easy to apply. The eyeliner created a "racoon effect" within a couple hours of wear, and had faded from where I had applied it. The longevity of wear was not good. The product fell out of the tube when I opened it. There's only about an inch of product. The pencil tube is plastic. You can't move the product up or down as it wears down. This pencil is not very useful. I'm disappointed by how careless and wasteful products have become. It's obvious that companies care more about making money and creating disposable waste than they do about making thoughtful products that don't add to the burden on the earth. I'm giving money to companies that care. Don't spend your money on a product.

3. Activated Eyeliner Blacklight Luminous Halloween

Activated Eyeliner Blacklight Luminous Halloween

These water activated eyeliner cake set could glow under the UV light. It is smudge proof, long lasting transfer resistant and won't fade until you remove it. This water activated face UV black light glow paint is a multi-functional paint that can be used for a variety of looks, from fine detailed lines to full-body art. It's great for face and body painting. This water activated face body eyeliner paint is easy to use and dries quickly, just dip a sponge or brush into the color and apply for a variety of looks or body art. It's perfect for Stars, Party Supplies,Nails,Balloons, Festivals,Clubs or Raves. You can wash off with soapy water or wet wipes. The water activated eyeliner set is very colorful, including red,hot pink, black, white, yellow,green, blue, purple and so on. Halloween Party Anywhere with UV Lighting is a large club where you can express yourself. All day glow colors are visible under natural light. Try it under blacklight to get those double takes. Face paints are vegan and Cruelty Free.

Brand: Ecofavor

👤Makeup types and this are the truest colors to use from the light source I have yet to use. I will be getting more in the future and recommend it to anyone who asks.

👤The yellow one was the only one that didn't work well. It was not flawless and left a mark on my eye. The other colors did not stay on. It was very smooth, no cracking at all. I wouldn't recommend wearing these when it's raining. It is running everywhere because of a small amount of water. I would recommend using a damp brush to clean up your liner. I got these for $18 instead of $25 because I don't like the neon yellow, and I still give this 5 stars. I would recommend friends to buy me more makeup stuffers, and I am buying more for my fellow makeup addicts.

👤The only downside was the hair at the bottom of one of the containers, I loved the color and how easy it was to use. It could be upsetting to other people who care about those things.

👤I was hesitant to purchase but I am so happy I did. I use all of the colors. It is possible that it will come off easily, but it usually holds up well. I can't wait to buy more!

👤I did not receive the whole kit. I only received 6 of the 10 colors I was supposed to get.

👤I liked how it looked.

👤The producto los colores son brillantes. Lpido y buen.

👤These liners are everything. They are buildable and don't sting if you accidentally get in your eye, I'm obsessed with them.

👤These are the first time that water activated liners have been used. They are amazing, apart from the fact that they need a 2 coat on white.

4. Honest Beauty Eyeliner Transfer Ophthalmologist

Honest Beauty Eyeliner Transfer Ophthalmologist

The formula is the same, but packaging may vary. Black liquid eyeliner is ultra-pigmented. The Self Healthy Beauty Awards are held in 2020. It lasts up to 8 hours without any issues. The Dermatologist and Ophthalmologist were tested. It's vegan and Cruelty free.

Brand: Honest Beauty

👤I can't wear eye makeup without it looking terrible. I live in the tropics. It is hot and humid here. I have oily skin and hooded eyes. When I blink my eyes, you can see an extra line on my lid. It looks worse throughout the day. I look like a mess by the end of the day. This eyeliner looks good after several hours in the heat, and it stays put. When my eyes touch, there is no extra line. There were no raccoon eyes. There was no smudge. A nice line that stays. I decided to give it a try. It comes off easily when I wash my face. It's easy to remove when I need it. I find waterproof eyeliners hard to remove. I stay away from them. This is perfect. The pictures are attached. When my eyes are open, there is a hood and makeup smudges. You can see my entire eyelid in the bottom picture. There is no smudge. The picture was taken after 5 hours of applying and running.

👤This is the best eyeliner on Amazon. That is not an eyeliner pencil. It's so natural it's not waterproof and can run. I love this eyeliner! I like to know what I'm putting on my body. I'm not sure what to say, but I like it, give it a try. There is a Please mark this review as helpful if it helped you make an informed purchase.

👤How do you get EWG verified? You pay for the work of EWG. The fee is based on company size, product, and other factors, but you will get a stamp of approval if you apply. Don't just trust something because it's EWG verified, do your own research. It's a scam. According to the FDA, this is not allowed in lip products. The government assessment cannot classify as human carcinogen due to data gaps, and it contains IRON OXIDES with limited or incomplete evidence of cancer. This eyeliner is not good.

👤I'm in love with this eyeliner. If I use most traditional makeup, I will break out in hives. This eyeliner does not cause any problems for my skin. I am happy! My go to for cat eyes.

👤I was not expecting much from this eyeliner. I needed an inexpensive liquid liner because I was trying to switch to cleaner beauty brands. The formula and brush work well. It seems to wear well, and I don't notice it. The color is very dark. I use a gel liner. I think I prefer this formula since I have always had issues with liquid liner. If you are looking for a good eyeliner, give this a try.

👤I've ever purchased the best liquid eyeliner. I am allergic to liquid eyeliners. My eye swells like a ballon. I look for eye products that are clean. I decided to give it a try after reading about it. I haven't had any allergic reactions yet. I don't think it smudges like I read. It will last all day until it is time to wash it off and it comes off easily with any makeup remover. This product is highly recommendable. Writing this review reminded me to stock up.

5. Cake Eye Liner Professional Size

Cake Eye Liner Professional Size

The cake eye liner formula is perfect. You're used to the smaller size with other brands.

Brand: Graftobian

👤I have used a brand of cake eyeliner from a department store for several years, but it rarely lasted all day and was a bit pricey. This is the first time I've tried a professional brand of liner and I am very impressed. The Expresso color is a dark brown. I love the fact that stays put all day long. The instructions said to use the Magic Set for long lasting waterproof results. I decided to use water instead of buying the "magic set" because it has out performed and out lasted my previous brand. It goes on smoothly, has not irritated my eyes, and dries quickly. It's cost effective as you get a large compact for less than fifteen dollars. There was a time when "cake" eyeliner and mascara were available. The only choices ladies had were. cake eyeliners have a bit of a learning curve since the 50-60's, so here is a suggestion to help first time users, don't soak the cake as this will only end up giving When applied, the line is very little color. The cake should disappear quickly if you add a small drop. Then swirl your brush to pick up the color after you add one or two more drops. If you want to achieve a thick line, you may have to add another drop of water. More water equates to less color and less water equates to darker color.

👤I am looking to make my makeup look better as I get older. This includes moving from blacks to brown, reds to brown, and pinks to neutral brown and pinks. This cake eyeliner is great for my "work look", it lasts all day but is easy to remove with makeup remover, and it is not too harsh a color. I use an angle brush that I picked up at a local art supply store rather than the one that comes with liquid eyeliner, and it makes a fine line on my lashes. There was no cat-eye or anything dramatic. I get a cleaner line if I wipe the brush on a tissue to get rid of excess water.

👤I love the cake liner. The brown cake powder that is the same color as the Graftobian Cake liner runs out of the colorant half way through when I purchase Clinique. I have three half used/useless ones that I thought I would send to the C company, but I have found a wonderful product that I should just trash. The product is easy to apply with water and seems to last the day without making my eyes tired. The price is much more reasonable. It's still a better quality than I wanted, but it's a bit higher.

👤I had been using the Fran Wilson brand, but it was not available on Amazon. I tried this brand. I love it! I think I might like it better than Fran Wilson. I will recommend this product to others.

👤Women of a certain age that used cake eyeliner back in the day are so happy to find it that they are overwhelmed with happiness, that all the positive reviews seem to be from. This review is for people who are just trying cake eyeliner for the first time, as it is the most wonderful product ever. There is a color. Some people think it is too light. You should add water. If you want it to be light, add a lot, if you want it to be dark, add a little. You have to add more water than you normally would to get the correct consistency, but after a few days you can easily monitor the water. You don't need a lot of droppers for the water. I keep the water in an old eye drop bottle, so it is easy to just use one or two drops. Some people wet the bush, but that has never worked for me. I used the dry brush to make a paste from the water. A brush. I have bought liner in the past that came with little brushes. You need a longer brush as you have to rest your hand on your cheek to get a smooth line. You don't need an expensive brush, but you do need a fine brush. I thought a paint brush was a good idea, but it wasn't very hard and scratched my eyelid. An expensive paint brush is not worth the bother. You don't need a big brush. The last one I bought was at the dollar store and it was great, I found the cheapest eyeliner brush over $20 and it was the right shape. It was the last package and the brushes will not last as long as the eyeliner so if you see a good deal get more than one. There is a Longevity. The cake eyeliner lasts a long time. It's not surprising that the companies that used to make it no longer do so. I found four Fran Wilson cake eyeliners in a store. I panicked as you couldn't buy cake eyeliner in the stores. I bought all four of them and am finishing the last one. You will have plenty of eyeliner left if you spend all your time experimenting with the amount of water and how to use it.

6. Black Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil Sharpener

Black Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil Sharpener

SMUDGE PROOF & BUDGE FREE is an unstoppable color that resists smudge and is easy to clean. Enjoy the best eyeliner with an ultra clean foundation. Attach your water line. The waterlines are where your eyes meet. Adding a touch of eyeliner to your waterline is a quick way to add definition to your eye makeup. Small eyes look bigger and big eyes look smaller with the help of dark smoky eyes. Your professional beauty possibilities are endless with Mia Adora. The Immovable eyeliner is waterproof and tears-proof. It holds up through the sweat and rain, as well as all the emotional moments from chick flicks, cute puppy videos and during that time of the month. It is easy to apply. Every time, draw-in precise winged eyeliner detail is used to create perfect cat's eyes. Smooth glide precision tip easily draws fine, thin, thick and captivatingly stunning line strokes on every eye shape. A pencil sharpener is included. Their 3D fudge mascara is a must have. The perfect match is an amazing mascara. To get the best results, use Immovable in combination with their 3D Fiber Mascara.

Brand: Mia Adora

👤The eye liner is amazing. I find it hard to find eyeliner that doesn'tirrp me all day through my eye rubbing, allergies, sweating, and just getting irritated from the eye liner. This stuff has held up. It doesn't bother my eyes like most of the other stuff. It is so easy to apply and I don't end up with tears running down my face just seconds after putting it on. I went to a Babymetal concert, if you don't know them you are missing out. I was jumping, screaming, and banging on the wall. It is a metal concert. The concert lasted 2 hours and included another metal band, 2 hours of sweating and a good time. I got out of my car expecting a big mess of a face, but my eye liner was still on! I fell asleep while we were at the hotel and woke up with my eye liner still on. What is this wonderful thing? How did they do it? My love for metal concerts is as big as my love for me.

👤This is the best eyeliner I have ever used. I like to wear eyeliner on my upper and lower water lines, but it's hard to find eyeliner that doesn't make me cringe. I love that this one is self sharpening. If you don't watch carefully when it gets dull, other eyeliners can scratch your eyes. I think it's more about the oil in your skin or makeup causing it to smudge, for those reviewers. I don't get smudges. I use ELF eye makeup under my eyes to keep them free of oil all day. This will be a regular purchase for me.

👤I've been using this for a while. I have a good opinion of it. It's a standard eyeliner pencil that is retractable and comes with a sharpener at the end. It's a pencil that's skinnier than the Colourpop liners. I used to only use eyeliner pencils, but got away from them when I became more comfortable with liquid liners. I got back into pencil liners for my lower waterline. I had to warm up the product before I applied so be sure to do it before application. I used it on my upper lashes and it was smooth. I wanted to test it on my water line. The tip of the sharpener broke off when I used it for the first time and it was frustrating because I lost a lot of product. It's a nice retractable pencil liner, but for me it wasn't revolutionary and was just like others I have used. The best eyeliner that stays in my waterline is the Colourpop liners, but I haven't found one that stays all day. The liner didn't last long in my waterline, but it did well on my upper lashline. I found that it transferred throughout the day. If you want to try out something new at a reasonable price, I think you should stick with the tried and true liner you have, but if you want to try something new, you should try it out.

7. Urban Decay Glide Pencil Perversion

Urban Decay Glide Pencil Perversion

Urban Decay's waterproof eyeliner pencils are award-winning, waterproof eyeliner pencils that deliver intense, long-wearing color that won't budge. Keep your eyeliner sharp with the Grind House Double Barrel Pencil Sharpener. There are five different finishes for their vibrant, stay-true shades. The blackest-black is called Perversion. The creamy formula glides on smoothly so you can draw a precise line, but stays soft so you can smudge. This eyeliner will last all day for wear. There are ingredients for moisturiZing. The eyeliner is made with hydrating ingredients. Jojoba oil and cottonseed oil condition and soothe the skin. Play well with other people and pair your eyeliner pencil with their Eyeshadow Primer Potion to create a custom cream eyeshadow.

Brand: Urban Decay

👤I'm always mad at myself for buying things on Amazon. I needed to replace my Buxom Insider Eyeliner. I ordered two because I read that Urban Decay is the closest. The first arrived quickly. I removed the cap from the pencil and saw that it had been used. I wanted to return it quickly. I made it sanitary by sharpening it. The second pencil was used but worse than the first. I was not comfortable. It goes on the inside of your eyelid. Who wants to get sick there? The seller was very nice. The other two were in an open box, and the pencil I received in exchange was also in an open box. The cap was dirty and smudged like the others. The point of the pencil was pushed in when I removed the cap. I was not sure if it could be sharpened. I wrote to the seller again to make her aware. I did not ask to return it. It wasn't worth the risk of another trip toUPS for us because we're in a house that's been sealed off. I wanted to make the seller aware that it is not a good practice to resell returned eyeliner pencils. I did not ask for anything after I sent her a photo of the pushed in point. She said that her items are new and unused. I will try to avoid buying cosmetics on Amazon in the future since I know how it is. Eye infections are the worst.

👤I tested the eyeliners to see which ones I liked the most. The waterline of the eye is what I apply my eyeliner to. I wanted an eyeliner that wouldn't smudge and wouldn't make me look like an animal. I didn't find any that were perfect. The highest rating I gave was 4 stars, and there were three that fit that rating. The list is from my least favorites to the highest. The Eyeliner Test was rated 4 stars by me. I rated it 4 stars because it doesn't smudge, it's easy to use, and it's fairly well all day. End of Day: still present, but is a little too messy for me, but it's pretty good. Application: easy, but messy, only sticks to the dry skin of the eyelid. The Lasts were not End of Day, but they were smooth and easy to apply. The name is Intense i-color Color: Raisin Quartz 004 and it barely shows up when applied.

👤You sent a used pencil and it was disappointing. Not only used, but without a cap, with fuzz attached to the eyeliner and stained with a blue paint. The experience was frightening.

👤For over an hour, I worked with it. I don't want to "glide on" here. It was hard, but not really. $30 was wasted. The "glide on:" was a selling point for me, as my eyes are no longer smooth. Don't need a product that accentuates it.

👤I've been using a black eyeliner by the end of the evening since the 90's. This goes on smoothly and stays put for at least 8 hours. It does what it says, but it's so soft it doesn't keep a point or stay sharp for long, so you can't really get a fine line. It's worth it.

8. Paris Voluminous Smoldering Eyeliner Packaging

Paris Voluminous Smoldering Eyeliner Packaging

The dark kajal formula is a richly intense black ingredient that glides on easily for a dramatic, captivating eye look. Choose from a variety of eyeliners, including gel, liquid felt tip, and pencil eye liners. They have a collection of mascaras, smudge proof eyeliner, add definition to your brows, and eye shadow palettes with shades made for every eye color. L'Oréal Paris has a full line of makeup that you can use to create the look you want. Voluminous Original Volume Building Mascara is a unique formula that can build lashes up to 5X their natural thickness.

Brand: L'oreal Paris

👤This liner is great. I should be getting my eye makeup toned down. I can't stand not having defined eyes. I use this liner to draw a thin line from the lower inner corner to the end of the lower lash line. I use an Urban Decay dark neutral to make the lines thicker. My teenage need for Big Eyes is met as well as my old lady need for some restraint, as I blend them with a'smudger'. I bought this liner in 'gray' and it works as a strong definer without being Too Black. The shape of this liner is very clever. You can use it to create a "kitten eye" through pressure alone. The thinner point at the inner corner is the best place to use to create a thicker line above the iris. Since I use eye drops a lot, I'm not the best judge. I highly recommend this liner.

👤I have used Kajal for as long as I can remember and there are many options in India. I don't like mechanical pencils because they are too dry and smudgeproof. I started making Kajal at home, it is smooth and black, like almond oil, almonds, and carrom seeds. I stopped using it because it smudged a bit too much. This Kajal is all chemicals, but which one isn't? This is less smudgy than a homemade Kajal, and I love it. Kajal's beauty is when it gets smudged a bit and gives her a sexy look.

👤I've been using this liner for a long time. The size helps my water lines. I use it for my water lines. The soft tip makes applying painless. Highly recommend!

👤I like the look of eyeliner but it always smudges on me and I look like a racoon by mid-day. I am terrible with liquid liner. I always use kohl pencils but thought there had to be a better way. This stuff is amazing. It glides on and stays put. I like using the color under my top lashes instead of putting it on the lid. The price is very reasonable. I will never buy a pencil again. I use this stuff in my makeup bag.

👤I have more eyeliners than I care to admit, and yet, I never tried this until the other day. It goes on the waterline. It smudges, but that is a good thing. I work the excess into my lid, and it is "smoldering" I have dark lids, so a smudge on my crease blended out is a full "lewk." If you're smart, you could put this in your purse and have it done. I recommend having a few Q-tips on hand to tighten up, and I found my finger did a good job of doing that. You do it. L'oreal, thank you for not making an eye product perfumed. I ordered a backup because I am certain it will last me a long time.

👤These pencils are not smudge proof. It's very easy to apply and the moment you touch your eyes, it's all over your face. I don't like the way it comes off and makes your face messy. It causes a lot of irritation in my eyes, I have used it a couple of times. I would never buy this again.

9. Pure Ziva Pressed Eyeliner Eyeshadow

Pure Ziva Pressed Eyeliner Eyeshadow

There are directions. Put a brush with water on top of the cake eye liner and make it soft. Made in the USA, no animal testing. There is a promotion. At checkout, use claim code PUREZIVA to get 10% off 2 items and 15% off 3 or more items. Sometimes pressed powders break in transit despite their best efforts. If you contact them, they'll replace/refund immediately. They are passionate about customer service, so if you want to be happy, please contact them.

Brand: Pure Ziva

👤This is advertised as pressed powder. The jar of black powder is a mess. There's nothing pressed about it. The lid gets on everything once it's opened. Will have to agree that it is a dark color. I used a brush that I bought in water and a little powder to make a paint palette and tried to apply it. Forget that. This item is not returnable. Everything through Amazon was returnable and free with Prime membership. I should have ordered the cake eyeliner from the first place. I think I've ever written a bad review. Very disappointed...

👤My review is being updated. Someone asked if I had noticed any issues with the skin. I have had no issues with this eyeliner since I have used it several times. I would have noticed it if there was any redness in my eyes. I have worn it in hot, dry and humid conditions. No running, no running, stays where I put it. When I first tried it out, I loved it. I ripped the box open with my teeth because I was so excited. I tried a little on my hand and it was what I was looking for. I don't like using eyeliner pencils and end up looking like a bad person when I try them. You wet and applied a eyeliner that I loved. My friend did the same and it turned out to be missing. I bought a wet and brush on eyeliner from Clinique several years ago, which I liked better than my other options at the time. I was coming to the end of its life. I wanted to find something similar to what I had in the past and hoped this would be it. As soon as the water touched the powder, I knew it was the same as my old one. I'm happy! It is a happy day. The color is rich and dark and just how I like it. I rubbed on it to see if it would stick. No lie. I don't wear makeup every day, and if this is the same as before, it will probably last me a long time. The seller wrote "Thank you" inside the box. Thank you. You have made me happy. I may have to wear make up more often.

👤It became harder to find Laura Mercier Tighline cake liner. I wanted to see how it would compare. First of all, great skin color. I don't like having to go over and over the line for definition, and this applied well the first time. The navy blue is more dark than the other brand, but I like the level of color. I was surprised that it stayed in place better than the other brand. It was still in place at the end of the day. It also removes easily with simple soap and water. There is no need for makeup removal or scrubbing in the delicate eye area. This is a winner. Think of dark forest and deep copper.

10. Maybelline New York Eyeliner Waterproof

Maybelline New York Eyeliner Waterproof

The liquid eyeliner has a hyper easy brush tip that makes it easy to glide over your eye. The Flex-Tip brush lasts up to 24 hours with intense color that doesn't smudge, and it has a hexagonal grip. It's all in the eyes, from subtle lines, smokey vibes, custom brow looks, classic tones or a shot of color; their eyeshadow, eyeliner, brows, and mascara collections are designed to transform your look. They're committed to celebrating beauty, self expression and creativity with their full line of makeup, from foundations to mascara, brow pencils, eyeliner and lipstick. Their mission is to offer innovative, accessible and effortless cosmetics for everyone.

Brand: Maybelline New York

👤The pros are 1. The brush tip is the best for liner into the inner rim and corner of the eyes. Safe formula for sensitive eyes. There was no smudge Con 1. The formula with low color pigmentation requires 3-4 strokes for dull black 2. Uneven Liquid distribution 3. The holding feature of hexagonal pen is nullified by a small diameter. Silly. 50% bigger will be perfect. 4. Water-proof is questionable as the color of the water starts to fade in a few hours. I don't recommend buying this pen at 4.5$ or NYX epic liner at the same price range. The Tattoo studio gel pencil is striking navy and has an eye liner in dark blue.

👤I like this eyeliner. I have tremors in my hand so when I put on an eyeliner I look for one that is easy to put on and clean up if I make a mistake. The only fault I have is closing it. It is difficult to close because of the design. It's pretty amazing so far.

👤This eyeliner is amazing. There is a design flaw in the packaging. The bristles lose their shape if you put the lid back on. There is no amount of straightening that will fix it. This product is useless because of that. It's a shame because it looks great on and stays on.

👤I've tried many brands but this one is the easiest to use and the best. It doesn't tug or skip when it's used properly and resists running when it's wet. I like to use liquid eyeliner on my top lid, but I find it hard to use it on my eyes because of their crepey appearance and fine lines. When I make an eyeliner "wing", the corners of my eyes tend to water and the wing looks terrible. This eyeliner is better than the previous ones I've tried. I haven't had an issue with it cracking for flaking. This is a great eyeliner for precision wings and details at an excellent price point. I would like to see more colors like bright blue or green. I would buy all of the colors.

👤I like to use brush eyeliners. I've tried the urban decay. This one is amazing. Especially for the price. Wing lines are much easier because it glides on so well. It is very bright. Will definitely do so.

👤I have eyeliner on all the time. I have very oily eyes and most eyeliners fail to stay put. I need a very waterproof and smudgeproof formula to look good most of the day before my oils ruin it. My eyeliners are opaque black with a brush tip. As opaque and fluid felt tip eyeliners are hard to control around my hooded eyes, they sometimes end up being dried out even though I have only used them a couple times. I've compared this eyeliner to other brands, such as NYX's Epic Ink Liner, MACQUEEN's waterproof, Heroine Make Smooth Liquid, Eyeko Black Magic, and KVD's Tattoo. I illustrated the 4 tests that I put each of these against. I've never found a formula that was as resistant as the new eyeliner from Maybelline. It's not as strong as my favorite life proof Asian eyeliners, but it's still very affordable and works well for most people. It makes nice lines for cat eyes. The hexagonal design and the tight feeling on my eyelid are things that I don't like, it's due to me being lazy and not wanting to stare and make sure I apply the cap back on correctly. The pen design is slimmer and more resistant to roll off a surface. The design is both pro and con for me. The eyeliner is lovely for most people with an affordable price. It's very easy to draw cat eyes or thin lines.

11. Jolie Extra Long Wear Eyeliner Black

Jolie Extra Long Wear Eyeliner Black

A rich color formula with great staying power. Smudge and transfer-resistant formula glides smoothly on the lashes. For a more defined look, apply their cake eyeliner sealant.

Brand: Jolie. Impeccable Me

👤I've been looking for a decent replacement for Fran Wilson's cake eyeliner. This isn't it. It was a disappointment that I tried Graftobian a few months ago. The container looked like it was from the movie "Gattobian" with the name on it. It's the same thing. It's hard to get off at the end of the day.

👤There are not enough cake eyeliner options. Longer lasting color is the same as others I have used, so it could be improved. It would be nice to have a brush option, but I am very happy with the inexpensive brush I found here, which was a suggestion when I searched for this one. I have never spent a lot of money for eyeliner so I can't compare it to expensive products, but in the price range it is about what I expected. This is not black-brown. If you're looking for darker than brown, this is not the one for you.

👤I used eyeliner in my teens. Many years ago! I use a fine liner artist brush and I love it. Just shorten the handle. It goes on fine and stays all day. Excellent quality. Thnaks.

👤I like dark brown eyeliner. This one is not dark at all. It is a very light brown. It's almost invisible by the end of the day. The fact that they call it Black-Brown is not true. I don't think you should.

👤I am very happy with this eyeliner. I used to love cake eyeliners, but for some reason went on to pencils and really hated liquid. I am so happy that I have returned to the cake variety. It goes on smoothly. I will purchase this product again.

👤I bought this eyeliner in black-brown. The dark color enhances the lashes without being harsh. The liner works well, but I need to go over the line twice to get even color. I used this with a brush and sponge and it was very easy to apply. I've used other cake liners and the cost is the same. I think most cake liners are a bit overpriced, but one cake should last a long time if you keep it clean.

👤I dropped this three inches onto my counter and it broke into a powdery mess. Not well packed! Quality compact makeup can break if dropped, but this exploded. It is not good quality.

👤The cake eyeliner is easy to apply. You can paint a thin line close to your lashes with a fine brush and a little water. It blends well and allows you to control the intensity.


What is the best product for cake eyeliner black?

Cake eyeliner black products from Nyx Professional Makeup. In this article about cake eyeliner black you can see why people choose the product. Julep and Ecofavor are also good brands to look for when you are finding cake eyeliner black.

What are the best brands for cake eyeliner black?

Nyx Professional Makeup, Julep and Ecofavor are some of the best brands that chosen by people for cake eyeliner black. Find the detail in this article. Honest Beauty, Graftobian and Mia Adora are also brands that their products are worth to check.

You May Like

Share Your Story

Your name:
Choose product to comment:
Write your review:
By submitting this review, you are agree that:
  • Your review is based on fact, honest, polite and not harmful to anyone or any brands.
  • We have full right to show or not-to-show your review after moderation.
  • No spamm please :)
We might earn comission for your shopping via our links, it doesn't cost you extra. This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to