Best Cake Eyeliner Dark Brown

Eyeliner 1 Oct 2022 10+ Comments Open

1. Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil Chocolate

Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil Chocolate

It glides on smoothly and lasts all day without fading or smudge. Light diffuses through the eyeliner pencil to make the whites of eyes appear brighter. The pencil has a built-in sharpener and smudger to help achieve a soft, blended, smoky eye look. The eye makeup formula is safe for sensitive eyes. The Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover can be used to remove this eyeliner.

Brand: Neutrogena

👤A really good eyeliner for blondes. For a while, I thought I would never be able to wear eyeliner again because of the red color, but I tried this one a while back. This brand and type is the only one that doesn't irritate my eyes and undereye skin. I would recommend this eyeliner to anyone who is sensitive to eyeliner.

👤I bought this for my mom, who cannot live without eyeliner. I've bought her many eyeliners. She prefers pens over liquid or gel. I've spent as little as $1 and as much as $25, but never found one that would stay for more than a few hours. She has 20 eyeliners that are ok. I bought this because she never used it and so far it's the only one she will use. She said that it works better than any of the other ones she owns, and that it lasts all day. The smudge end was lost in a few days and that's why I have a 4 star rating. It came right away. She eventually found it.

👤It's easy to apply and gives a nice soft look rather than the sharp outline of a liquid liner. I have a tip for other women with a fair complexion and light colored eyes, stop trying to achieve the "smoky eye" look. It doesn't work for our coloring. This will make you look like the sister of "The Hamburglar".

👤I just got my order and it went on smoothly, I don't have to use eyeliner pens or make me cry. It has been on for at least 15 minutes and my eyes don't feel dry or itchy. It is soft so don't expect crisp lines. I'm planning on using different ones for different accents. I will buy more colors in the future. I have been told for 20 years that I would get used to makeup and not tear up. 3

👤This is the only eyeliner I have found that stays put and doesn't rub off in my waterline. I have been using it for a long time and will not use another one.

👤I switched to this eyeliner after several bouts of blepharitis. I thought my mascara was causing the problem, but after trying several brands without success, I decided to change my eyeliner and the problem was solved. I was devastated to have to switch brands after using L'Oreal's Infallible Never Fail Eyeliner for 10 years. I wear eyeliner everyday and wanted a cheaper alternative that was comparable to my beloved L'Oreal liner, and could be purchased at the drugstore. The only two drugstore brands I could find were Neutrogena liner and Physician's Formula Eye Definer Automatic Eye Pencil. Both brands did not cause any irritation. The Physician's Formula liner wears off very quickly, which left me with the Neutrogena liner as my best option. I don't notice any fading/wearing off until the end of the day, and this one stays on well compared to my old L'Oreal liner. This Neutrogena eyeliner is a close second to my favorite L'Oreal liner and it does not bother or irritate my eyes at all. I think the Neutrogena liner is just as easy to apply as the L'Oreal liner, and it also has a nice, solid color when applied, which is something I never got with the Physician's Formula eyeliner. If you're looking for a non-irritating eyeliner, Neutrogena is the product for you.

2. 1Black Eyeliner Eyebrow Brushes Included

1Black Eyeliner Eyebrow Brushes Included

The gel eyeliner kit comes with two classic colors, black and brown, which are perfect for daily eyeliner or eyebrow makeup. The creamy gel with its light and supple texture helps you easily clear the eyeliner line and provides a waterproof, non-blooming effect. This gel is smudgeproof and can stay on for a whole day. Provide 2 small eye makeup brushes, one regular liner brush, and one angle liner brush, they help you easily create different eyeliner, such as doing a good wing. This is a must have set for different occasions, perfect for party makeup, casual makeup, wedding makeup, etc. You will love it.

Brand: Ucanbe

👤There is so much to like about these jars. The suggestion that you get what you pay is true, but in this case the value is extraordinary. I thought I'd try them, even though my expectations were low. They are better than the price would suggest. Two colors, black and brown. Two uses, eyeliner and brows. There are two brushes. There is a color. I don't want the more dramatic black eyeliner, so I use this one for a subtler effect when I don't want a brown one. In the short video I made applying this, I held the camera with one hand, and the brush with the other, and it stayed on. Quite the challenge. The gel stays liquid for a short time so it doesn't smudge and it dries just right so it doesn't oxidize. There are some things that are CONS: 1) Some reviewers think the brushes are not top-notch. Really? The brushes work. They do the job, even though they are not the best ever. Are you really expecting two jars of exceptional product and two brushes that are designer labels for under $6? Overall, I'm blown away by this product and the exceptional value it offers.

👤The product is amazing. I use brown for filling in my brows and black for lining my waterline. One of the reasons I love it is that it is very versatile. It should last a while because a little goes a long way. I did my makeup this morning. My brows haven't budged since 6 pm.

👤I have never tried a product like that before. I put a picture of my makeup application on my face. There were no signs of coming off or being smeared. I will recommend this item to everyone and will come back for more once I need it.

👤I have been looking for a great brow kit and this is it. I think it is amazing and my eyebrows look great. I mean, all of you see it right. The eyeliner is great. The texture of the gel makes it easy to apply. You know it will last you a while. The brushes are workable but not the best. Next time, I will use my own liner brush and brow brush. If you want to save some money, this is a must.

👤The black and brown eyeliners are my favorites. The color is great. The eyeliners are not shiny when they dry. They don't give up. I like the brush that comes with them. These work well for my winged looks. My eyes tear up a lot when I have allergies. One of the easier waterproof liners I have to remove. I will be ordering again. I have had these for several months and have only put a small dent in them.

👤Where has this product been all my life? I've tried tons of eyeliners that promise not to smudge or run, but only to be disappointed time and again. I'm not prone to give up easily. I saw this product at Amazon. I thought I would give it a try because it had good reviews. The packaging was intact when I received the order. I was very impressed with the overall look of the product. I tried the gel eyeliner. I like mixing brown and black together to get the exact match for my skin tone and this product was flawless. I wore it for 16 hours and it never ran. It was smudge proof and was easy to remove with my eye makeup wipes. If you are looking for a gel eyeliner that will stay in place and won't fade or feather, then this is the product for you. I am very happy with my purchase. I will purchase this item again as Christmas gifts for my girlfriends.

3. Urban Decay Glide Pencil Perversion

Urban Decay Glide Pencil Perversion

Urban Decay's waterproof eyeliner pencils are award-winning, waterproof eyeliner pencils that deliver intense, long-wearing color that won't budge. Keep your eyeliner sharp with the Grind House Double Barrel Pencil Sharpener. There are five different finishes for their vibrant, stay-true shades. The blackest-black is called Perversion. The creamy formula glides on smoothly so you can draw a precise line, but stays soft so you can smudge. This eyeliner will last all day for wear. There are ingredients for moisturiZing. The eyeliner is made with hydrating ingredients. Jojoba oil and cottonseed oil condition and soothe the skin. Play well with other people and pair your eyeliner pencil with their Eyeshadow Primer Potion to create a custom cream eyeshadow.

Brand: Urban Decay

👤I'm always mad at myself for buying things on Amazon. I needed to replace my Buxom Insider Eyeliner. I ordered two because I read that Urban Decay is the closest. The first arrived quickly. I removed the cap from the pencil and saw that it had been used. I wanted to return it quickly. I made it sanitary by sharpening it. The second pencil was used but worse than the first. I was not comfortable. It goes on the inside of your eyelid. Who wants to get sick there? The seller was very nice. The other two were in an open box, and the pencil I received in exchange was also in an open box. The cap was dirty and smudged like the others. The point of the pencil was pushed in when I removed the cap. I was not sure if it could be sharpened. I wrote to the seller again to make her aware. I did not ask to return it. It wasn't worth the risk of another trip toUPS for us because we're in a house that's been sealed off. I wanted to make the seller aware that it is not a good practice to resell returned eyeliner pencils. I did not ask for anything after I sent her a photo of the pushed in point. She said that her items are new and unused. I will try to avoid buying cosmetics on Amazon in the future since I know how it is. Eye infections are the worst.

👤I tested the eyeliners to see which ones I liked the most. The waterline of the eye is what I apply my eyeliner to. I wanted an eyeliner that wouldn't smudge and wouldn't make me look like an animal. I didn't find any that were perfect. The highest rating I gave was 4 stars, and there were three that fit that rating. The list is from my least favorites to the highest. The Eyeliner Test was rated 4 stars by me. I rated it 4 stars because it doesn't smudge, it's easy to use, and it's fairly well all day. End of Day: still present, but is a little too messy for me, but it's pretty good. Application: easy, but messy, only sticks to the dry skin of the eyelid. The Lasts were not End of Day, but they were smooth and easy to apply. The name is Intense i-color Color: Raisin Quartz 004 and it barely shows up when applied.

👤You sent a used pencil and it was disappointing. Not only used, but without a cap, with fuzz attached to the eyeliner and stained with a blue paint. The experience was frightening.

👤For over an hour, I worked with it. I don't want to "glide on" here. It was hard, but not really. $30 was wasted. The "glide on:" was a selling point for me, as my eyes are no longer smooth. Don't need a product that accentuates it.

👤I've been using a black eyeliner by the end of the evening since the 90's. This goes on smoothly and stays put for at least 8 hours. It does what it says, but it's so soft it doesn't keep a point or stay sharp for long, so you can't really get a fine line. It's worth it.

4. Clinique Quick Liner Smoky Brown

Clinique Quick Liner Smoky Brown

A richly colored eyeliner pencil for instant intensity. The eyeliner glides on to a smooth blur of color. The smudge tool is on the opposite end of the applicator.

Brand: Clinique

👤Don't buy eyeliner on Amazon. The eyeliner was packaged in a box. I usually buy eye liner at a department store. I ordered it a few months ago and just opened it today and it's old and useless. You have to press very hard to make it show up. I had to return it by the date I missed. There is nothing you can do about it. Beware. Don't buy Clinique products on Amazon. You can't be sure that it is usable.

👤I have been using this product for a long time, but is it possible to get it here? Never again. The product is done after being used twice. shame on you, for people like me who have little money to spare, and for people like you who are doing a lot of scamming.

👤This product was not good. The mechanism doesn't twist and make it useless after a few uses.

👤I fell in love with the smoke-blue color of the two Clinique eyeliner pencils I bought many years ago. I searched for a replacement at several upscale stores, but found it on Amazon. I don't understand why anyone would give this product a poor review. The pencil that arrived was just as smooth and creamy as my original. To apply is a dream.

👤I have begun to develop eye makeup allergies. My eyes turn red when I see my old favorites. This eyeliner has not bothered me at all. It applies quickly and doesn't wear off too quickly. It is black with a hint of blue, but it doesn't look blue after being applied.

👤Amazon told me to contact the seller after I wrote a review. There is no way to contact a seller. I used it twice after receiving it. It won't be used again. Its not right. They wouldn't post my last review as they said it was. I don't know who the seller was. There are other people who have had a problem with this product. I would like a solution to this problem. Not a happy customer!

👤I had forgotten what I should not do. This eye liner does not cause me allergies. I love it! The pencil is very easy to use.

👤This is a great eyeliner for people over 50. It doesn't apply without "stuttering" but it is not too soft. I don't have to pull my lid taut because it glides across my wrinkled skin. It lasts about 12 hours for me before it needs touch-up, but you'll sacrifice a bit for the ease of application. The color is soft grey, which is more blue than grey. Doesn't bother my eyes at all. I liked this one so much that I ordered another. I am happy I found it.

5. Jolie Extra Long Wear Eyeliner Black Brown

Jolie Extra Long Wear Eyeliner Black Brown

A rich color formula with great staying power. Smudge and transfer-resistant formula glides smoothly on the lashes. For a more defined look, apply their cake eyeliner sealant.

Brand: Jolie. Impeccable Me

👤I've been looking for a decent replacement for Fran Wilson's cake eyeliner. This isn't it. It was a disappointment that I tried Graftobian a few months ago. The container looked like it was from the movie "Gattobian" with the name on it. It's the same thing. It's hard to get off at the end of the day.

👤There are not enough cake eyeliner options. Longer lasting color is the same as others I have used, so it could be improved. It would be nice to have a brush option, but I am very happy with the inexpensive brush I found here, which was a suggestion when I searched for this one. I have never spent a lot of money for eyeliner so I can't compare it to expensive products, but in the price range it is about what I expected. This is not black-brown. If you're looking for darker than brown, this is not the one for you.

👤I used eyeliner in my teens. Many years ago! I use a fine liner artist brush and I love it. Just shorten the handle. It goes on fine and stays all day. Excellent quality. Thnaks.

👤I like dark brown eyeliner. This one is not dark at all. It is a very light brown. It's almost invisible by the end of the day. The fact that they call it Black-Brown is not true. I don't think you should.

👤I am very happy with this eyeliner. I used to love cake eyeliners, but for some reason went on to pencils and really hated liquid. I am so happy that I have returned to the cake variety. It goes on smoothly. I will purchase this product again.

👤I bought this eyeliner in black-brown. The dark color enhances the lashes without being harsh. The liner works well, but I need to go over the line twice to get even color. I used this with a brush and sponge and it was very easy to apply. I've used other cake liners and the cost is the same. I think most cake liners are a bit overpriced, but one cake should last a long time if you keep it clean.

👤I dropped this three inches onto my counter and it broke into a powdery mess. Not well packed! Quality compact makeup can break if dropped, but this exploded. It is not good quality.

👤The cake eyeliner is easy to apply. You can paint a thin line close to your lashes with a fine brush and a little water. It blends well and allows you to control the intensity.

6. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Powder Eyeliner

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Powder Eyeliner

A pressed powder eyeliner duo with a bright color payoff. Two absolutely essential shades of black and brown are included. Use a brush to apply eyeliner. The brush needs to be wet to get the payoff. The item is new and unused.

Brand: Nyx Professional Makeup

👤I thought the cake eyeliner was supposed to have water added to it to make it liquid. That is my understanding of what a cake eyeliner is supposed to be. It's not worth the high cost if it's only suppose to be applied dry. I could use my own shadows to do the same thing. While working the droplets in with a liner brush, the dry powder of the cake sat atop the brush, refusing to reabsorb any moisture, because the product is so dehydrated that it does not want to absorb any water. It dropped onto everything. Face mostly. I give it a single star rating because of this.

👤It was broken within its container. The dust is pure. I had to go back and get another. I was disappointed that the replacement had no brush. I had to buy a brush kit because I didn't know the size. I tried it with several brushes. I had to remove the makeup from my eye because of the powder. I had to blow on the brush and shake it off. Didn't go as smoothly as I had hoped. Disappointed.

👤I have had this for about a month. I love using cake eyeliners. This is a mixed review. The black does not absorb liquid. I've tried water and cake eyeliner sealant, but it doesn't stick to the powder. I have to use a lot of the powder to get the liquid out of the cake, because it does absorb. The way I have used cake eyeliners in the past is the same way I use the brown cake. I am trying to make it work so it doesn't work the way it should.

👤The eyeliner is very messy and difficult to apply. The cake doesn't stick to the brush if you use a wet or dry brush. If you're not careful, it can fall out of your eye area. The powder beads up and rolls off the surrounding surfaces if you wet it. It's nearly impossible to get the water beads and powder to fit into the brush. You have a blob at the tip of the brush. If you can get any of this product onto your eye, the color intensity is inconsistent and cannot be applied very darkly. The photo of my eye was taken with the brush. It's not ideal for a winged look because it smudges out over the course of an evening. It's difficult to remove once it is smudged and faint.

👤I have been using cake eyeliner for a long time. I applied this liner to my eyes. There were black arches on my upper lids when I arrived at my friends wedding. One hour. I don't carry makeup in my purse. I only apply lipstick once I reach my destination. It isn't on my face when I leave the house. I had to remove my eye makeup at the event, and as a result only mascara was left. I didn't want to use public restroom soap, paper towel, or eye makeup on my clothes because it was annoying. There is no recommendation here.

7. Minerals Lasting Long Wearing Eyeliner Brown

Minerals Lasting Long Wearing Eyeliner Brown

The color is long-wearing and richly pigmented. A blend of minerals and vitamins for soothing. The package is 1.3 cm long and 1.9 cm wide.

Brand: Bareminerals

👤I am very pleased with the eyeliner. I don't wear eyeliner anymore and don't like the smoky eye that has become popular again, so I don't do it. I have found my eyelashes getting more sparse if you do. I didn't have many to begin with. Young women can do whatever they want with their makeup because they are so beautiful. I feel like I'm wearing a mask when I wear heavy eye makeup. It makes me feel great to find a lovely eyeliner that I can apply very close to my lashes and help fill in what I've lost. It goes on without a hitch and the vampire is not looking. The eyeliner is soft and the point is small. I am careful to keep it turned down to what I need so as not to break it.

👤This is the worst. My husband ordered this item for Christmas. It came used. Terrible. I was excited for my husband to get me this and other products because I had admired Bare Minerals. I'm disgusted. I will return the product. We paid full asking price and got less than we deserved.

👤I love BM makeup, but I don't like this kind of pencil, it's too expensive to have it break so easy. waste It's really

👤This liner is not really waterproof. The pencil broke off on the second use. It is very difficult to sharpen. I got a piece of pencil. Half the length was lost. May be old.

👤A perfect eyeliner for a woman who hates her job. It lasts through all the tears in the car after a long day.

👤Really disappointed in bare minerals. The wear is not good and it is hard to get an even coverage.

👤Great eyeliner. As pictured, color goes on smoothly.

👤I have had about 5 of them, and they don't last very long. Even with a little pencil showing, the tip keeps breaking off. I can't afford these for a small amount of eyeliner.

👤This product is easy to clean. I've never used eyeliner that does what it says. I've used a lot of expensive eyeliner products. Really like it!

👤I like my eyeliner the most. The colour stays on all day. It is easy to use and has a Blending end as well.

👤The item was well received. I have never used eyeliner before, but it didn't smudge the entire day, and I will use it again.

👤I like this product, it still looks good at the end of the day. It ran out after a couple months, so I'm not giving it a 5. I've used other twist-up eyeliners for at least 3 months.

8. Maybelline New York Eyeliner Waterproof

Maybelline New York Eyeliner Waterproof

The liquid eyeliner has a hyper easy brush tip that makes it easy to glide over your eye. The Flex-Tip brush lasts up to 24 hours with intense color that doesn't smudge, and it has a hexagonal grip. It's all in the eyes, from subtle lines, smokey vibes, custom brow looks, classic tones or a shot of color; their eyeshadow, eyeliner, brows, and mascara collections are designed to transform your look. They're committed to celebrating beauty, self expression and creativity with their full line of makeup, from foundations to mascara, brow pencils, eyeliner and lipstick. Their mission is to offer innovative, accessible and effortless cosmetics for everyone.

Brand: Maybelline New York

👤The pros are 1. The brush tip is the best for liner into the inner rim and corner of the eyes. Safe formula for sensitive eyes. There was no smudge Con 1. The formula with low color pigmentation requires 3-4 strokes for dull black 2. Uneven Liquid distribution 3. The holding feature of hexagonal pen is nullified by a small diameter. Silly. 50% bigger will be perfect. 4. Water-proof is questionable as the color of the water starts to fade in a few hours. I don't recommend buying this pen at 4.5$ or NYX epic liner at the same price range. The Tattoo studio gel pencil is striking navy and has an eye liner in dark blue.

👤I like this eyeliner. I have tremors in my hand so when I put on an eyeliner I look for one that is easy to put on and clean up if I make a mistake. The only fault I have is closing it. It is difficult to close because of the design. It's pretty amazing so far.

👤This eyeliner is amazing. There is a design flaw in the packaging. The bristles lose their shape if you put the lid back on. There is no amount of straightening that will fix it. This product is useless because of that. It's a shame because it looks great on and stays on.

👤I've tried many brands but this one is the easiest to use and the best. It doesn't tug or skip when it's used properly and resists running when it's wet. I like to use liquid eyeliner on my top lid, but I find it hard to use it on my eyes because of their crepey appearance and fine lines. When I make an eyeliner "wing", the corners of my eyes tend to water and the wing looks terrible. This eyeliner is better than the previous ones I've tried. I haven't had an issue with it cracking for flaking. This is a great eyeliner for precision wings and details at an excellent price point. I would like to see more colors like bright blue or green. I would buy all of the colors.

👤I like to use brush eyeliners. I've tried the urban decay. This one is amazing. Especially for the price. Wing lines are much easier because it glides on so well. It is very bright. Will definitely do so.

👤I have eyeliner on all the time. I have very oily eyes and most eyeliners fail to stay put. I need a very waterproof and smudgeproof formula to look good most of the day before my oils ruin it. My eyeliners are opaque black with a brush tip. As opaque and fluid felt tip eyeliners are hard to control around my hooded eyes, they sometimes end up being dried out even though I have only used them a couple times. I've compared this eyeliner to other brands, such as NYX's Epic Ink Liner, MACQUEEN's waterproof, Heroine Make Smooth Liquid, Eyeko Black Magic, and KVD's Tattoo. I illustrated the 4 tests that I put each of these against. I've never found a formula that was as resistant as the new eyeliner from Maybelline. It's not as strong as my favorite life proof Asian eyeliners, but it's still very affordable and works well for most people. It makes nice lines for cat eyes. The hexagonal design and the tight feeling on my eyelid are things that I don't like, it's due to me being lazy and not wanting to stare and make sure I apply the cap back on correctly. The pen design is slimmer and more resistant to roll off a surface. The design is both pro and con for me. The eyeliner is lovely for most people with an affordable price. It's very easy to draw cat eyes or thin lines.

9. Pure Ziva Chocolate Eyeliner Eyeshadow

Pure Ziva Chocolate Eyeliner Eyeshadow

There are directions. Put a brush with water on top of the cake eye liner and make it soft. Made in the USA, no animal testing. There is a promotion. At checkout, use claim code PUREZIVA to get 10% off 2 items and 15% off 3 or more items. Sometimes pressed powders break in transit despite their best efforts. If you contact them, they'll replace/refund immediately. They are passionate about customer service, so if you want to be happy, please contact them.

Brand: Pure Ziva

👤This is advertised as pressed powder. The jar of black powder is a mess. There's nothing pressed about it. The lid gets on everything once it's opened. Will have to agree that it is a dark color. I used a brush that I bought in water and a little powder to make a paint palette and tried to apply it. Forget that. This item is not returnable. Everything through Amazon was returnable and free with Prime membership. I should have ordered the cake eyeliner from the first place. I think I've ever written a bad review. Very disappointed...

👤My review is being updated. Someone asked if I had noticed any issues with the skin. I have had no issues with this eyeliner since I have used it several times. I would have noticed it if there was any redness in my eyes. I have worn it in hot, dry and humid conditions. No running, no running, stays where I put it. When I first tried it out, I loved it. I ripped the box open with my teeth because I was so excited. I tried a little on my hand and it was what I was looking for. I don't like using eyeliner pencils and end up looking like a bad person when I try them. You wet and applied a eyeliner that I loved. My friend did the same and it turned out to be missing. I bought a wet and brush on eyeliner from Clinique several years ago, which I liked better than my other options at the time. I was coming to the end of its life. I wanted to find something similar to what I had in the past and hoped this would be it. As soon as the water touched the powder, I knew it was the same as my old one. I'm happy! It is a happy day. The color is rich and dark and just how I like it. I rubbed on it to see if it would stick. No lie. I don't wear makeup every day, and if this is the same as before, it will probably last me a long time. The seller wrote "Thank you" inside the box. Thank you. You have made me happy. I may have to wear make up more often.

👤It became harder to find Laura Mercier Tighline cake liner. I wanted to see how it would compare. First of all, great skin color. I don't like having to go over and over the line for definition, and this applied well the first time. The navy blue is more dark than the other brand, but I like the level of color. I was surprised that it stayed in place better than the other brand. It was still in place at the end of the day. It also removes easily with simple soap and water. There is no need for makeup removal or scrubbing in the delicate eye area. This is a winner. Think of dark forest and deep copper.

10. Music Flower Waterproof Long Lasting Smudge Proof

Music Flower Waterproof Long Lasting Smudge Proof

This set is perfect for basic eye make up, with 2 small eye liner makeup applicators, one angle, and normal. 2 Pieces eyeliner gel with its light and supple texture help you easily depict the smooth eyeliner create you a natural eye makeup. The creamy gel is made of waterproof and long wear formula with delicate and silky texture. It is easy to carry out. Take part in a personal eye painting. It is easy to remove makeup. 100% Brand factory development and manufacturing.

Brand: Music Flower

👤I wore this eyeliner to work. I don't like eyeliner that looks bad 8 hours into my hospital shift. This is the worst yet. I looked like a Raccoon within an hour. The eyeliner smudged over my eyelid like black eyeshadow and I couldn't get it to wipe off until I got home and scrubbed it with eye makeup remover! Don't waste your money on smudgeproof, waterproof gel eyeliner. It is not those things. It is a big fat joke.

👤The eyeliners are great. If you are looking for a medium brown or one with lots of red in it, this isn't it. They are both glossy, with no sparkle, and I would call them a patent finish. You need to remember that the liner dries fast. I have not been brave enough to use these in my waterline. If we ever get to travel again, the set of black and brown came with a stiff brush and a little brown one, which will come in handy. I tried mixing a bit of brown with some light taupe eyeshadow and using it to do my eyebrows. It stayed for 14-hours and was brilliant.

👤After Urban decay discontinued ink for your eyes in the early 2000s I was on a search for a smudge free cream like eyeliner pot and after reading reviews I decided to try this. This smudged within 2 hours. After baking under my eyes, I had raccoon eyes. The only liners that don't smudge are felt tip. Cream based is very easy to use. I will continue my search.

👤I have searched for eyeliner that doesn't smudge under my eyes so many times that I end up taking most of it off within an hour. On a hot day, I wore eyeliner that held the whole time. I like to use brown and black eyeliner when I wear makeup. I highly recommend! It's a good thing.

👤This is what I get for being cheap. It's a bad product. You can't make straight lines because the gel dries into a tack. You can save an extra $10 and get a better product. Don't treat yo'self cheap.

👤These go on without a hitch. The quality and ease of use were very good. They were very inexpensive and much more than I expected. The brown and black are gorgeous. I would order it again.

👤I washed dishes and showered. Has not moved or faded. You will need a quality brush to get a sharp look. Don't bother with the brushes included. I intend to use this exclusively. Anything else. It was a steal for the money.

👤I like that I was able to find a gel pot that was both brown and black. I would have preferred that one of the two brushes had bee thinner.

👤It's creamy, long-wearing, and bright. I was surprised by the quality. I have oily skin and sometimes my gel liner transfers on me. I have not had that problem with this one. I have used it a number of times and I can say that it stayed all day and didn't move to my under eyes. I put this on bare lids and it stayed all day.

11. Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Kajal Liner

Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Kajal Liner

It won't smudge from day to night. A high intensity color impact. It is smooth and creamy. The eye doctor was tested. It is suitable for contact lens wearers.

Brand: Rimmel

👤I found a waterproof pencil eyeliner that I wanted. I decided to put it through a test. I ran on the treadmill after putting a thick line under my eye. 30 minutes later, not waterproof at all. It would run if I had it all day. Oh well. On to the next.

👤If you watch my video, you will see why I no longer buy the eyeliners that roll out on their own. They break on me. That money is going down the drain. I got two eyeliners for less than $8. I haven't tried the black yet, but the brown is a nice medium brown. I'm expecting it to be as good as the brown. I need these eyeliners to go on smoothly because of my dry 50 year old skin. The brown smudged a bit after 8 hours of wear, but nothing that a quick brush of my fingers couldn't fix. I don't wear a lot of make up so my base is a light cream. I like the quality and price of these eyeliners. I'm going to buy more colors.

👤I like it. How do you make this thing sharper? I tried a makeup pencil sharpener, but it wouldn't fit, and then I tried a normal pencil sharpener, but it just fell off. I can barely use it now because it is not sharp. They should include a sharpener for this pencil.

👤I agree with the customer who said that they have spent a lot of money on upper end eyeliners, only to have them pull the skin in order to get the waterproof effect on. I can't believe that I've changed my eyeliners. The self sharpening kind breaks easily. If you make it halfway on one of those puppies, you're lucky. I don't like to wear liquid eyeliners because they pull the tender skin by your eye. The product goes on without a hitch because it's called Kohl. Keep a steady hand. If you make a mistake it is hard to correct. Just keep going all day. I fell asleep with it and didn't wake with any of the eye problems. I use a non oil based pad to take it off, you will need something stronger than soap and water to take it off. I'm sure you can, but it would take a long time. It's a good thing. I like the fact that I have control over the sharpening. Self sharpening eyeliners don't have good control over how they are applied. I keep mentioning that those kinds break off. I paid $35 for a brand name one and only got to use half of it before it broke. I don't like to flush money. The quality of the product is amazing and the price is amazing. This pencil will make you golden. I put a picture on here so you can see it when it's on. I put on the eyeliner and decided I wanted a more smoky look for the evening so I added a line under the original one. This pencil is thin or thick and easy to use, so you will hopefully enjoy it as much as I do! Happy shopping! j

Summary

What is the best product for cake eyeliner dark brown?

Cake eyeliner dark brown products from Neutrogena. In this article about cake eyeliner dark brown you can see why people choose the product. Ucanbe and Urban Decay are also good brands to look for when you are finding cake eyeliner dark brown.

What are the best brands for cake eyeliner dark brown?

Neutrogena, Ucanbe and Urban Decay are some of the best brands that chosen by people for cake eyeliner dark brown. Find the detail in this article. Clinique, Jolie. Impeccable Me and Nyx Professional Makeup are also brands that their products are worth to check.

You May Like

Share Your Story

Your name:
Choose product to comment:
Write your review:
By submitting this review, you are agree that:
  • Your review is based on fact, honest, polite and not harmful to anyone or any brands.
  • We have full right to show or not-to-show your review after moderation.
  • No spamm please :)
Disclaimer
We might earn comission for your shopping via our links, it doesn't cost you extra. This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com