Best Cake Eyeliner Gray

Eyeliner 25 Sep 2022 10+ Comments Open



A pressed powder eyeliner duo with a bright color payoff. Two absolutely essential shades of black and brown are included. Use a brush to apply eyeliner. The brush needs to be wet to get the payoff. The item is new and unused.

Brand: Nyx Professional Makeup

👤I thought the cake eyeliner was supposed to have water added to it to make it liquid. That is my understanding of what a cake eyeliner is supposed to be. It's not worth the high cost if it's only suppose to be applied dry. I could use my own shadows to do the same thing. While working the droplets in with a liner brush, the dry powder of the cake sat atop the brush, refusing to reabsorb any moisture, because the product is so dehydrated that it does not want to absorb any water. It dropped onto everything. Face mostly. I give it a single star rating because of this.

👤It was broken within its container. The dust is pure. I had to go back and get another. I was disappointed that the replacement had no brush. I had to buy a brush kit because I didn't know the size. I tried it with several brushes. I had to remove the makeup from my eye because of the powder. I had to blow on the brush and shake it off. Didn't go as smoothly as I had hoped. Disappointed.

👤I have had this for about a month. I love using cake eyeliners. This is a mixed review. The black does not absorb liquid. I've tried water and cake eyeliner sealant, but it doesn't stick to the powder. I have to use a lot of the powder to get the liquid out of the cake, because it does absorb. The way I have used cake eyeliners in the past is the same way I use the brown cake. I am trying to make it work so it doesn't work the way it should.

👤The eyeliner is very messy and difficult to apply. The cake doesn't stick to the brush if you use a wet or dry brush. If you're not careful, it can fall out of your eye area. The powder beads up and rolls off the surrounding surfaces if you wet it. It's nearly impossible to get the water beads and powder to fit into the brush. You have a blob at the tip of the brush. If you can get any of this product onto your eye, the color intensity is inconsistent and cannot be applied very darkly. The photo of my eye was taken with the brush. It's not ideal for a winged look because it smudges out over the course of an evening. It's difficult to remove once it is smudged and faint.

👤I have been using cake eyeliner for a long time. I applied this liner to my eyes. There were black arches on my upper lids when I arrived at my friends wedding. One hour. I don't carry makeup in my purse. I only apply lipstick once I reach my destination. It isn't on my face when I leave the house. I had to remove my eye makeup at the event, and as a result only mascara was left. I didn't want to use public restroom soap, paper towel, or eye makeup on my clothes because it was annoying. There is no recommendation here.

2. LUXAZA Eyeliner Waterproof Lasting Creamy

LUXAZA Eyeliner Waterproof Lasting Creamy

TheLUXAZA Gel Eyeliner Set is a set. The eyeliner set has black and espresso gel eyeliner and delicate eye makeup brushes. The texture is soft and smooth. The black and coffee gel eye liner can be used to create a 3D natural eyebrow. Cream Eyeliner Gel is a creamy gel eyeliner that glides on smooth to intense colors that just go on in a swipe. There are advanced colors that can match eye makeup. It is smudge-proof to keep it on for up to 24 hours. After using the eyeliner brush, wipe it clean with a paper towel. Smudge-proof and waterproof. The eyeliner gel black set contains waterproof formula to make your eyebrows last all day without smudges. It's easy to use, it goes on smooth with a brush in an easy dip and stroke action, and it has a silkier and softer finish, if you don't want to wear heavy makeup. They are not tested on animals. The ingredients used to create the perfect eyeliner are safe for people with allergies.

Brand: Luxaza

👤Great eye makeup. I have always had a problem with my makeup being smudged and this is easy to use.

👤I've tried a lot of products. This one lasts all day.

👤I like the liner. It's easy to apply creamy liner. It's a nice brown. I have only begun using it. I don't know how well it holds up, but so far it's been good.

👤It goes on smoothly and lasts all day. I love this stuff. This doesn't bother me because I have hooded eyelid and eyeliner that rubs off. It's amazing.

👤I like this product a lot and I encourage you to work with it for a little while before giving up. Oh, that's right. I had to do that. I'm glad I did.

👤It works well. It is a great deal. Maui is from Honolulu.

👤I put a gel shadow on top and it has lasted all day. I was worried that it would smudge or slip, because it was smooth and creamy. No, no. It wouldn't budge after I swiped it on. I tried to make it look smoky. Would not move. I am very happy about it. I will add a shadow along the line to create a shadow effect. The liner works. Both colors are bright. They layer under other shades nicely. I don't know what else to put, but you should buy!

👤I wanted brown eyeliner. The brush is too big for the fine line I like, but it didn't matter because the product is not creamy, so I had clumps, and it is waterproof. If you need something else to put in your trash can, skip this one.

3. Maybelline Eyestudio Master Precise Eyeliner

Maybelline Eyestudio Master Precise Eyeliner

No Smudge Black Liquid Eyeliner has an ultra fine tip that stays put for up to 12 hours with any look you're working on. Define your eye with a long lasting intense color and sharp lines that are fragrance free and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. It's all in the eyes, from the subtle lines to the smokey vibes, their eyeshadow, eyeliner, brows and mascara collections are designed to transform your look. Make eye looks with eyeshadows, brow pencils and eyeliners, and perfect your lips with lipsticks and lip balms. The number one makeup brand, they make no hassle, high performance makeup for every look, style and skin tone, so whatever the world throws at you, you'll look and feel ready.

Brand: Maybelline New York

👤Smudges are not waterproof. I applied liner to my eyelid and within 3 hours the line was gone and my eyelid was smeared. I live in a hot climate and not lasting more than 3 hours is ridiculous.

👤I have found a brown eyeliner that doesn't dry out and goes on smoothly. It's a bottle with a wand, but it's a beautiful coppery brown. I'll review it soon. I have eyeliner in both black and brown. The black works well for a long time. The brown only applies for a few applications. It seems a little dry and skips after a while. It's still the best brown pen-style eyeliner I've found, so I get it every month in my subscribe and save order, and the price is definitely right. I'm still looking for a better brown. If you have found my review helpful, I would appreciate if you would click theHelpful button. Thank you so much for reading! Liz

👤The way this liner goes on and the color I loved made me give this one star. It was dried out after only 3 uses. I put the cap on in my make-up bag, so it was on the side. I thought there was a twist mechanism on the top or bottom to release the liquid, but it wasn't. I tried to wet the tip and then press it down on the hard surface to get the liquid out. Nothing worked. Very disappointed.

👤This is awesome. Most seem to dry out in a few weeks. I've been using this for months and it works perfectly. I like a very thin eyeliner line. It works very well when I wear my eyeliner thick. Great eyeliner. It's not 100% waterproof but it doesn't look as bad as others. I work as a mail carrier and am in 90 weather for 6 hours. I don't look like I have eyes like that. Highly recommended.

👤I would have liked this product if there was something else in it. The first day I tried it, there was some present, but not enough to use it, so I put the cap back on it. It went on without a hitch. I can't afford to buy one every day. I might try it again if it was a success because I liked it, but I feel ripped off even though it was not expensive. I can try another seller or find it locally.

👤Where has this been my entire life? I ordered this in a moment of weakness. The pen tip is perfect. It is easy to use and look good. If I make the lines even, I can use a cotton swab and some makeup oil or water to clean them. It lasts too. I tend to have oily skin and my eyeliner doesn't make it all day and evening but it lasts. I am impressed and recommend this to anyone who is looking to keep their liner on point. The price in Amazon is great.

👤I can buy this product again and again. It's perfect for my eyebrows. I do it like a blading with it and it looks amazing. You can see how I did it in my video. The color is intense but not as intense as a 24 hour product. I think it's like an eyeliner.

4. Physicians Formula Enhancing Universal Collection

Physicians Formula Enhancing Universal Collection

Ultra shimmery glitter eyeliner pencils define and lighten eyes instantly for a long- lasting glamorous look. The eyes are thin enough to closely line, and have a high amount of color and shimmer. PHYSICIAN'S FORMULA EYE LINER. Their eyeliner pens and eyeliner pencils are safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. They glide on smoothly for a defined eye. Physician's Formula has everything you need to draw eyes, from their eye enhancing eyeshadow pallet and eyelash eyeliners, to their Eye Boosters and 2-in-1 eyeliner and eye primer. Physician's Formula has a full line of makeup and skin care for sensitive skin. Their products are safe for sensitive skin and eyes. Beauty products that are healthy. All of their products are safe for sensitive skin and eyes, and are created without any of the harsh ingredients found in other personal care items.

Brand: Physicians Formula

👤I use the EWG skin deep database to research and choose natural products for myself and my family. The safety of each ingredient and the overall safety of the product are rated by this database. The majority of the ingredients are rated 1 or 2. Three ingredients aren't as safe. D&C Black 2 (3) is a aluminum powder. I like the product. It goes on without a hitch. It will smudge a bit throughout the day, but it lasts well. The dark one works best for me as the lighter ones are meant to be nude so they don't show up well. If the company would change some of the ingredients, I would love it.

👤The company has lost sight of why its customers became customers. I started using their eye products because they made my eyes red and itchy. Theirs used to be. All eye products now have glitter, which goes directly in the eye. Why does eye liner need glitter? You can see pieces of it coming off when you apply the eye liner. Completely defeats the purpose! It is very hard and you have to press more than you should. The liner breaks off when I try to use the sharpener. Terrible product. I wish they still sold the brown eye liner. Something simple that won't make eye sensitivity worse is all I need.

👤I apologize for the awkward, squinty pics, but I had to share them. The picture was taken after a nursing school clinical. There is a mental health hospital. It wasn't a stress free shift. I sweat a lot today in the chaos and this eyeliner has begun to transfer onto my upper eyelid. I am amazed. I have always been an oily person and have never had luck getting eyeliners to stay put because of the oiliness. I have bought cheap eyeliners, liquid eyeliners, long-wear liners, and every other type in between, and I can not remember a single one that I didn't have these issues with. I was not expecting much when I ordered this 3-pack for $7. I was feeling cheap that day and wanted some new liners. I decided to give them a try after reading a lot of positive reviews. Was not upset! The lightest brown shade I have used so far is called 'champagne' according to the box. I had to review this one because I was expecting a mess in the mirror when I got home from the hospital and to my amazement there was no mess at all! I decided to rate these as a 4 because it took a bit of elbow grease to get it on, and as a pasty white lady, it's still too light for me. I drew in the line over and over until I got the stick to go on and I didn't have to figure out how to warm it up. My only complaints are those. It is a shimmery light brown, perfect for work or school, and I only had to use it for a few hours on my greasy eyelids. It makes blue eyes pop, so I think that is good. As I get to use the other 2 colors, I will try to update this later. The next dark brown stayed on during an hour long gym workout without being transferred or smudged, and the shower afterwards with some smudge action beginning. I am not good at it. I have never found an eyeliner that stays put. Updating to 5 stars now!

5. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Waterproof Eyeliner


The waterproof eyeliner from NYX Professional is perfect for long- lasting cat eye looks. Precise tip: The tip is easy to use. For a defined finish, every stroke is unbelievably fluid. Pressing down just a touch will control the thickness of your lines. The look is always up to you. All eyes on eye makeup. Their NYX Professional Makeup eye makeup products include eyeshadow to mascara, eyeliners, concealers, setting sprays, and eyebrow products. It is free of contraceptives. They don't think animals belong in a lab. All of their makeup is certified and acknowledged by the animal rights group. They don't test their products on animals. Discover New York professional makeup. Try all of their professional makeup and beauty products today.

Brand: Nyx Professional Makeup

👤I have heavy lids that have deflated, and now sit on my lashes. Any eyeliner will transfer because of this? I'll have a copy of the perfect line if I sweat or cry. There is a I was trying them all, but I didn't have any luck. I bought this one. I was about to give it the ultimate test when this one came. My husband passed away after fighting cancer for 4 years. I still love him even though he was my everything. I wore this to the funeral and everyday since he died. I've shed buckets of tears because it's in the 90's and 100% humidity here in Ohio, and I've sweated rivers as well. Not a single transfer, smudge or fade away! I hope you don't have to worry about your liner. If you cry happy tears or sweat, you can count on this one more than any other one I've tried.

👤I don't usually write reviews, but I had to rave about this eyeliner because it's amazing. I used to use the tattoo liner from Von D, but this is my new favorite. The quality is even better and it's $10 cheaper. I would want my eyeliner to be perfect. It's waterproof, very black, easy to use, and has a thin tip so you can get wings as sharp as a sword. I don't need to do any maintenance with this because I use makeup remover and concealer to clean up my lines. My cat's eyes are looking great. I wanted to say that their packaging might have been faulty because I had no problem with my eyeliner, even though a lot of reviewers were complaining about how it bled everywhere. I have never used eyeliners that bleed less than mine.

👤It works like a charm. I will not give her my money to spread anti-science rhetoric about vaccines. If not better, this NYX is less than half the price. Good job NYX. The cap would catch part of the brush when I put it on. It was hard to apply the eyeliner because of the brush hairs sticking out in different directions. It is most likely my fault to put the cap on. It sucks.

👤This stuff is amazing. I've been using the kat von d tatoo liner, but since she's canceled, I've been looking for a sub that's more affordable, and this one was perfect. It's very bright! I have a deep complexion and it doesn't smudge. It makes a clean cat eye. happy with it

👤Most of the reviews were positive. I should have paid more attention to the negatives. I received this yesterday and have only used it once, but have been wiping smudges off my face all day. I don't know what the product the positive reviewers were using was, but they said it was waterproof and smudge-proof. The best eye-liner ever! I'm looking for a product that I can recommend. This one was very disappointing.

👤I have eyeliner on all the time. I have very oily eyes and most eyeliners fail to stay put. I need a very waterproof and smudgeproof formula to look good most of the day before my oils ruin it. My eyeliners are opaque black with a brush tip. As opaque and fluid felt tip eyeliners are hard to control around my hooded eyes, they sometimes end up being dried out even though I have only used them a couple times. I've compared NYX eyeliner to some of my favorite brands, such as Maybelline's Hyper Easy, MACQUEEN's waterproof, Heroine Make Smooth Liquid, Eyeko Black Magic, and KVD's Tattoo Liner. I illustrated the 4 tests that I put each of these against. The only formula I've ever found to dry down and be resistant was the new eyeliner from Maybelline. My favorite Asian eyeliners are waterproof and inexpensive. Eyeko is a brand that lasts well. I've allowed that to slide because EM Cosmetics did not claim to be waterproof. I'm not surprised that the formula didn't last because I've never liked it. NYX's formula isn't horrible and would work well for most people, but it can't last through my eyes. I love how fluid the formula is and how opaque it is. It's easy to do graphic liners. It's great for creating quick and easy wings since it's so pigmented. I am going to use a primer or powder because I am enjoying it. If you don't have crazy oily eyes and would like a dark and even application with a brush tip eyeliner, I would highly recommend this eyeliner. I'm sure one could make it work with some preparation.

6. REVLON Waterproof Smudgeproof Longwearing Ultra Fine

REVLON Waterproof Smudgeproof Longwearing Ultra Fine

Waterproof eye liner: long wear. Their cult-classic, longwear pencil eyeliner has a waterproof formula that lasts up to 24 hours and has a smooth, creamy glide. Up to 24 hour wear. For smudge-proof looks that stay with you all day, this eyeliner stays put for up to 24 hours. A built-in sharpener and smudger are included to make your eyes look smoldering and smoky. A multitude of eyeliner looks can be created from defined to dramatic, winged liner, cat eye liner, and more. There are 8 ophthalmologist-tested shades for the 10 Instinct Shades. That glides on smooth.

Brand: Revlon

👤I've never used a makeup brand, but this one time it turned me off. The product was years old and they had shipped it to me from the back corner of a warehouse. Bummed. I know a lot of people who like this product, but I was not offered any kind of compensation other than a coupon that had to be used on their website. It was not worth the risk of ordering again.

👤I've ordered it from Amazon a few times and it hasn't worked out. The product came in good condition once. The tip of the pencil breaks off easily. I was good to go, I would just sharpen it a little with the built in sharpener. The most recent time that I ordered from here, it was terrible. The pencil broke easily. I thought there was a metal rod in the middle of the crumbled outer layers because they were so hard. The pencil had a foul odor and that signals to me that the pencil has expired. I used eyeliner because I needed it, but it irritated my eyes. It's not a good idea to use expired makeup. The pencil should be good, but you should buy it from your local drugstore.

👤This works well for my upper lid line application, it is easy to apply and does not cause any harm if rubbed. Is waterproof and lasts me my entire work shift of 10 hours. It is easy to remove make-up. I like to use black because it is true to its color and not faded like some other eyeliners. I don't use smudge and pull-out sharpeners. It is an option if I wanted to try different things. I've been applying the upper lid line for a long time and I've gotten good at it. I know how to wear it. I subscribe to Amazon for every 3 months because I liked this so much. It lasts me over 3 months with almost daily use.

👤I tried a set of new ones, but they still break off. I don't know if you're going to try to make them sharper. It made them worse. I've ordered 4 pencils with the same results. I tried to roll up the color, but it didn't work, so it's a shame. The pencils are a pretty color. I would love to send them back. I can't. I paid a lot of money for them. I would take a different type of pencil. I would like my money back.

👤My eyeliner is my absolute favorite. It's all I use. In my state the drug stores jacked up the price so I buy if off Amazon now. It's black and lasts almost all day before fading. It's easy to apply, you just have to get used to the amount of pressure you use, since the tip can break with too much. This is a waterproof eyeliner, so you need makeup pads that specifically remove waterproof products. I've used Neutrogena and Olay brand pads, both work fine, it's whatever is cheaper or preferable.

7. Cake Eye Liner Professional Size

Cake Eye Liner Professional Size

The cake eye liner formula is perfect. You're used to the smaller size with other brands.

Brand: Graftobian

👤I have used a brand of cake eyeliner from a department store for several years, but it rarely lasted all day and was a bit pricey. This is the first time I've tried a professional brand of liner and I am very impressed. The Expresso color is a dark brown. I love the fact that stays put all day long. The instructions said to use the Magic Set for long lasting waterproof results. I decided to use water instead of buying the "magic set" because it has out performed and out lasted my previous brand. It goes on smoothly, has not irritated my eyes, and dries quickly. It's cost effective as you get a large compact for less than fifteen dollars. There was a time when "cake" eyeliner and mascara were available. The only choices ladies had were. cake eyeliners have a bit of a learning curve since the 50-60's, so here is a suggestion to help first time users, don't soak the cake as this will only end up giving When applied, the line is very little color. The cake should disappear quickly if you add a small drop. Then swirl your brush to pick up the color after you add one or two more drops. If you want to achieve a thick line, you may have to add another drop of water. More water equates to less color and less water equates to darker color.

👤I am looking to make my makeup look better as I get older. This includes moving from blacks to brown, reds to brown, and pinks to neutral brown and pinks. This cake eyeliner is great for my "work look", it lasts all day but is easy to remove with makeup remover, and it is not too harsh a color. I use an angle brush that I picked up at a local art supply store rather than the one that comes with liquid eyeliner, and it makes a fine line on my lashes. There was no cat-eye or anything dramatic. I get a cleaner line if I wipe the brush on a tissue to get rid of excess water.

👤I love the cake liner. The brown cake powder that is the same color as the Graftobian Cake liner runs out of the colorant half way through when I purchase Clinique. I have three half used/useless ones that I thought I would send to the C company, but I have found a wonderful product that I should just trash. The product is easy to apply with water and seems to last the day without making my eyes tired. The price is much more reasonable. It's still a better quality than I wanted, but it's a bit higher.

👤I had been using the Fran Wilson brand, but it was not available on Amazon. I tried this brand. I love it! I think I might like it better than Fran Wilson. I will recommend this product to others.

👤Women of a certain age that used cake eyeliner back in the day are so happy to find it that they are overwhelmed with happiness, that all the positive reviews seem to be from. This review is for people who are just trying cake eyeliner for the first time, as it is the most wonderful product ever. There is a color. Some people think it is too light. You should add water. If you want it to be light, add a lot, if you want it to be dark, add a little. You have to add more water than you normally would to get the correct consistency, but after a few days you can easily monitor the water. You don't need a lot of droppers for the water. I keep the water in an old eye drop bottle, so it is easy to just use one or two drops. Some people wet the bush, but that has never worked for me. I used the dry brush to make a paste from the water. A brush. I have bought liner in the past that came with little brushes. You need a longer brush as you have to rest your hand on your cheek to get a smooth line. You don't need an expensive brush, but you do need a fine brush. I thought a paint brush was a good idea, but it wasn't very hard and scratched my eyelid. An expensive paint brush is not worth the bother. You don't need a big brush. The last one I bought was at the dollar store and it was great, I found the cheapest eyeliner brush over $20 and it was the right shape. It was the last package and the brushes will not last as long as the eyeliner so if you see a good deal get more than one. There is a Longevity. The cake eyeliner lasts a long time. It's not surprising that the companies that used to make it no longer do so. I found four Fran Wilson cake eyeliners in a store. I panicked as you couldn't buy cake eyeliner in the stores. I bought all four of them and am finishing the last one. You will have plenty of eyeliner left if you spend all your time experimenting with the amount of water and how to use it.

8. Jolie Extra Long Wear Eyeliner Black Brown

Jolie Extra Long Wear Eyeliner Black Brown

A rich color formula with great staying power. Smudge and transfer-resistant formula glides smoothly on the lashes. For a more defined look, apply their cake eyeliner sealant.

Brand: Jolie. Impeccable Me

👤I've been looking for a decent replacement for Fran Wilson's cake eyeliner. This isn't it. It was a disappointment that I tried Graftobian a few months ago. The container looked like it was from the movie "Gattobian" with the name on it. It's the same thing. It's hard to get off at the end of the day.

👤There are not enough cake eyeliner options. Longer lasting color is the same as others I have used, so it could be improved. It would be nice to have a brush option, but I am very happy with the inexpensive brush I found here, which was a suggestion when I searched for this one. I have never spent a lot of money for eyeliner so I can't compare it to expensive products, but in the price range it is about what I expected. This is not black-brown. If you're looking for darker than brown, this is not the one for you.

👤I used eyeliner in my teens. Many years ago! I use a fine liner artist brush and I love it. Just shorten the handle. It goes on fine and stays all day. Excellent quality. Thnaks.

👤I like dark brown eyeliner. This one is not dark at all. It is a very light brown. It's almost invisible by the end of the day. The fact that they call it Black-Brown is not true. I don't think you should.

👤I am very happy with this eyeliner. I used to love cake eyeliners, but for some reason went on to pencils and really hated liquid. I am so happy that I have returned to the cake variety. It goes on smoothly. I will purchase this product again.

👤I bought this eyeliner in black-brown. The dark color enhances the lashes without being harsh. The liner works well, but I need to go over the line twice to get even color. I used this with a brush and sponge and it was very easy to apply. I've used other cake liners and the cost is the same. I think most cake liners are a bit overpriced, but one cake should last a long time if you keep it clean.

👤I dropped this three inches onto my counter and it broke into a powdery mess. Not well packed! Quality compact makeup can break if dropped, but this exploded. It is not good quality.

👤The cake eyeliner is easy to apply. You can paint a thin line close to your lashes with a fine brush and a little water. It blends well and allows you to control the intensity.

9. Pure Ziva Pressed Eyeliner Eyeshadow

Pure Ziva Pressed Eyeliner Eyeshadow

There are directions. Put a brush with water on top of the cake eye liner and make it soft. Made in the USA, no animal testing. There is a promotion. At checkout, use claim code PUREZIVA to get 10% off 2 items and 15% off 3 or more items. Sometimes pressed powders break in transit despite their best efforts. If you contact them, they'll replace/refund immediately. They are passionate about customer service, so if you want to be happy, please contact them.

Brand: Pure Ziva

👤This is advertised as pressed powder. The jar of black powder is a mess. There's nothing pressed about it. The lid gets on everything once it's opened. Will have to agree that it is a dark color. I used a brush that I bought in water and a little powder to make a paint palette and tried to apply it. Forget that. This item is not returnable. Everything through Amazon was returnable and free with Prime membership. I should have ordered the cake eyeliner from the first place. I think I've ever written a bad review. Very disappointed...

👤My review is being updated. Someone asked if I had noticed any issues with the skin. I have had no issues with this eyeliner since I have used it several times. I would have noticed it if there was any redness in my eyes. I have worn it in hot, dry and humid conditions. No running, no running, stays where I put it. When I first tried it out, I loved it. I ripped the box open with my teeth because I was so excited. I tried a little on my hand and it was what I was looking for. I don't like using eyeliner pencils and end up looking like a bad person when I try them. You wet and applied a eyeliner that I loved. My friend did the same and it turned out to be missing. I bought a wet and brush on eyeliner from Clinique several years ago, which I liked better than my other options at the time. I was coming to the end of its life. I wanted to find something similar to what I had in the past and hoped this would be it. As soon as the water touched the powder, I knew it was the same as my old one. I'm happy! It is a happy day. The color is rich and dark and just how I like it. I rubbed on it to see if it would stick. No lie. I don't wear makeup every day, and if this is the same as before, it will probably last me a long time. The seller wrote "Thank you" inside the box. Thank you. You have made me happy. I may have to wear make up more often.

👤It became harder to find Laura Mercier Tighline cake liner. I wanted to see how it would compare. First of all, great skin color. I don't like having to go over and over the line for definition, and this applied well the first time. The navy blue is more dark than the other brand, but I like the level of color. I was surprised that it stayed in place better than the other brand. It was still in place at the end of the day. It also removes easily with simple soap and water. There is no need for makeup removal or scrubbing in the delicate eye area. This is a winner. Think of dark forest and deep copper.

10. Julep Pencil Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner

Julep Pencil Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner

PENCIL HAD GEL ALL-DAY LONG WEAR. It will stay on your top or bottom lashes for at least 10 hours and is safe for waterlines. This eyeliner pencil glides smoothly on your lashes and sets for a long- lasting finish that's been tested for 10 hours of wear. This gel eyeliner is made with a special wax blend that ensures color glides on gently without tugging or skipping. It works well for both top lashes and your inner waterline. The high- performance pigments give a bold color payoff all day long. The unique formula combines the ease of a regular eyeliner pencil with the smoothness of a gel eyeliner, so you'll get perfect, vibrant color in a single swiped. There are a variety of shades, including bold black and classic neutrals, available in both shimmer and matt finishes. There are a variety of shades, including bold black and classic neutrals, available in both shimmer and matt finishes. How to apply? It's safe for the waterline and you can glide this gel eyeliner pencil easily. Do you want a smoky finish? Smudge gently with your fingers or a brush.

Brand: Julep

👤The gel pencil stays put all day. It took me a while to figure out that you can use a pencil sharpener to sharpen this, even though you are not using wood. It does work, but you might need to clean the blades with alcohol if they get gummed up, and if you find the pencil spinning without sharpening. Try putting the pencil in the freezer for an hour.

👤The struggle is real and I have a makeup addiction. I'm an equal opportunity makeup nerd, I have everything from bargain to luxury cosmetics. I have very sensitive eyes and I need to be very careful when selecting eye products that contain glitter or shine. I gave it a try in the hopes that it would work for me. The Julep "When Pencil Met Gel" Long Lasting Gel Eyeliner is a medium sized pencil. It glides on smoothly and is easy to smudge or blend if done immediately, so it's important to smudge it upon application. I have dry eyes. I didn't have any problems with applying this. The liner was put in place all day. The shade is shimmery, not overly shiny, but it's enough to make my eyes brighter. It's very pretty and has become my go to liner for everyday wear. It's similar to the Stila 24 Hour eyeliner pencil but less expensive. This is my first Julep purchase, but it won't be my last. It's a lovely formula. I'm very impressed!

👤I have tried many waterproof eyeliner pencils over the years and this one is by far the best. The pencil does not break when it is sharpened. The infused gel allows for a smooth gliding application without tugging at delicate eye tissue. The eyeliner stays on all day. It comes in my favorite color, forest green, which makes my hazel eyes brighter. I hope that this product will be around for a long time since it is difficult to find superior makeup.

👤This eyeliner was too dark for my skin tone and age. It was easy to apply for me. I was hoping for a little more light plum, but it lasted all day and I used it lightly. It was too harsh for a lady my age. I'll either stick to the right colors or look for a lighter shade of plum. My granddaughters will be happy to use this. It will not go to waste. There is no picture submitted at this time.

👤I've been looking for makeup brands that are vegan, cruelty-free and made with clean ingredients, and that care about the environment. It seemed like it would fit my criteria after reading so many positive reviews. The eyeliner was easy to apply. The eyeliner created a "racoon effect" within a couple hours of wear, and had faded from where I had applied it. The longevity of wear was not good. The product fell out of the tube when I opened it. There's only about an inch of product. The pencil tube is plastic. You can't move the product up or down as it wears down. This pencil is not very useful. I'm disappointed by how careless and wasteful products have become. It's obvious that companies care more about making money and creating disposable waste than they do about making thoughtful products that don't add to the burden on the earth. I'm giving money to companies that care. Don't spend your money on a product.

11. Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Kajal Liner

Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Kajal Liner

It won't smudge from day to night. A high intensity color impact. It is smooth and creamy. The eye doctor was tested. It is suitable for contact lens wearers.

Brand: Rimmel

👤I found a waterproof pencil eyeliner that I wanted. I decided to put it through a test. I ran on the treadmill after putting a thick line under my eye. 30 minutes later, not waterproof at all. It would run if I had it all day. Oh well. On to the next.

👤If you watch my video, you will see why I no longer buy the eyeliners that roll out on their own. They break on me. That money is going down the drain. I got two eyeliners for less than $8. I haven't tried the black yet, but the brown is a nice medium brown. I'm expecting it to be as good as the brown. I need these eyeliners to go on smoothly because of my dry 50 year old skin. The brown smudged a bit after 8 hours of wear, but nothing that a quick brush of my fingers couldn't fix. I don't wear a lot of make up so my base is a light cream. I like the quality and price of these eyeliners. I'm going to buy more colors.

👤I like it. How do you make this thing sharper? I tried a makeup pencil sharpener, but it wouldn't fit, and then I tried a normal pencil sharpener, but it just fell off. I can barely use it now because it is not sharp. They should include a sharpener for this pencil.

👤I agree with the customer who said that they have spent a lot of money on upper end eyeliners, only to have them pull the skin in order to get the waterproof effect on. I can't believe that I've changed my eyeliners. The self sharpening kind breaks easily. If you make it halfway on one of those puppies, you're lucky. I don't like to wear liquid eyeliners because they pull the tender skin by your eye. The product goes on without a hitch because it's called Kohl. Keep a steady hand. If you make a mistake it is hard to correct. Just keep going all day. I fell asleep with it and didn't wake with any of the eye problems. I use a non oil based pad to take it off, you will need something stronger than soap and water to take it off. I'm sure you can, but it would take a long time. It's a good thing. I like the fact that I have control over the sharpening. Self sharpening eyeliners don't have good control over how they are applied. I keep mentioning that those kinds break off. I paid $35 for a brand name one and only got to use half of it before it broke. I don't like to flush money. The quality of the product is amazing and the price is amazing. This pencil will make you golden. I put a picture on here so you can see it when it's on. I put on the eyeliner and decided I wanted a more smoky look for the evening so I added a line under the original one. This pencil is thin or thick and easy to use, so you will hopefully enjoy it as much as I do! Happy shopping! j


What is the best product for cake eyeliner gray?

Cake eyeliner gray products from Nyx Professional Makeup. In this article about cake eyeliner gray you can see why people choose the product. Luxaza and Maybelline New York are also good brands to look for when you are finding cake eyeliner gray.

What are the best brands for cake eyeliner gray?

Nyx Professional Makeup, Luxaza and Maybelline New York are some of the best brands that chosen by people for cake eyeliner gray. Find the detail in this article. Physicians Formula, Nyx Professional Makeup and Revlon are also brands that their products are worth to check.

You May Like

Share Your Story

Your name:
Choose product to comment:
Write your review:
By submitting this review, you are agree that:
  • Your review is based on fact, honest, polite and not harmful to anyone or any brands.
  • We have full right to show or not-to-show your review after moderation.
  • No spamm please :)
We might earn comission for your shopping via our links, it doesn't cost you extra. This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to